(H.) Parties directly opposite,
Assist each other, as ’twere for spight: Page 10. Line 5.
NOthing was more instrumental in forwarding the Reformation, than the
Sloth and Stupidity of the Roman Clergy; yet the same Reformation
has rous’d ’em from the Laziness and Ignorance they then labour’d under;
and the Followers of Luther, Calvin, and others, may be said to
have reform’d not only those whom they drew in to their Sentiment,
but likewise those who
remain’d their greatest Opposers.
The Clergy of England by being severe upon the Schismaticks, and
upbraiding them with want of Learning, have raised themselves such
formidable Enemies as are not easily answer’d; and again, the Dissenters
by prying into the Lives, and diligently watching all the Actions of their
powerful Antagonists, render those of the Establish’d Church more cautious
of giving Offence, than in all probability they would, if they had no
malicious Over-lookers to fear. It is very much owing to the great number
of Hugonots that have always been in France, since the late
utter Extirpation of them,
that that Kingdom has a less dissolute and more learn’d Clergy to
boast of than any other Roman Catholick Country. The Clergy of that
Church are no where more Sovereign than in Italy, and therefore no
where more debauch’d; nor any where more Ignorant than they are in
Spain, because their Doctrine is no where less oppos’d.
Who would imagine, that Virtuous Women, unknowingly, should be
instrumental in promoting the Advantage of Prostitutes? Or (what still
seems the greater Paradox) that Incontinence should be made serviceable to
the Preservation of Chastity? and yet nothing is more true. A vicious
young Fellow, after having been an Hour or two at Church, a Ball, or any
other Assembly, where there is a great parcel of handsome Women dress’d to
the best Advantage, will have his Imagination more fired than if he had
the same time been Poling at Guildhall,
or walking in the Country among a Flock of Sheep. The consequence of this
is, that he’ll strive to satisfy the Appetite that is raised in him; and
when he finds honest Women obstinate and uncomatable,
’tis very natural to think, that he’ll hasten to others that are more
compliable. Who wou’d so much as surmise, that this is the Fault of the
Virtuous Women? They have no Thoughts of Men in dressing themselves, Poor
Souls, and endeavour only to appear clean and decent, every one according
to her Quality.
I am far from encouraging Vice, and think it would be an
unspeakable Felicity to a State, if the Sin of Uncleanness could be
utterly Banish’d from it; but I am afraid it is impossible: The Passions
of some People are too violent to be curb’d by any Law or Precept; and it
is Wisdom in all Governments to bear with lesser Inconveniences to prevent
greater. If Courtezans and Strumpets were to be prosecuted with as much
Rigour as some silly People would have it, what Locks or Bars would be
sufficient to preserve the Honour of our Wives and Daughters? For ’tis not
only that the Women in general would meet with far greater Temptations,
and the Attempts to ensnare the Innocence of Virgins would seem more
excusable even to the sober part of Mankind than they do now: But some Men
would grow outrageous, and Ravishing would become a common Crime. Where
six or seven Thousand Sailors arrive at once, as it often happens at
Amsterdam, that have seen none but their own Sex for many Months
together, how is it to be suppos’d that honest Women should walk the
Streets unmolested, if there were no Harlots to be had at reasonable
Prices
? For which Reason the Wise Rulers of that well-order’d City always
tolerate an uncertain number of Houses, in which Women are hired as
publickly as Horses at a Livery-Stable; and there being in this Toleration
a great deal of Prudence and Oeconomy to be seen, a short Account of
it will be no tiresome digression.
In the first place the Houses I speak of are allowed to be no where but
in the most slovenly and unpolish’d part of the Town, where Seamen and
Strangers of no Repute chiefly Lodge and Resort. The Street in which most
of them stand is counted scandalous, and the Infamy is extended to all the
Neighbourhood round it. In the second, they are only Places to meet and
bargain in, to make Appointments, in order to promote Interviews of
greater Secrecy, and no manner of Lewdness is ever suffer’d to be
transacted in them; which Order is so strictly observ’d, that bar the ill
Manners and Noise of the Company that frequent them, you’ll meet with no
more Indecency, and generally less Lasciviousness there, than with us are
to be seen at a Playhouse. Thirdly, the
Female Traders that come to these Evening Exchanges are always the Scum of
the People, and generally such as in the Day time carry Fruit and other
Eatables about in Wheel-Barrows. The Habits indeed they appear in at Night
are very different from their ordinary ones; yet they are commonly so
ridiculously Gay, that they look more like the Roman Dresses of
stroling Actresses
than Gentlewomen’s Clothes: If to this you add the aukwardness, the hard
Hands, and course breeding of the Damsels that wear them, there is no
great Reason to fear, that many of the better sort of People will be
tempted by them.
The Musick in these Temples of Venus is performed by Organs,
not out of respect to the Deity that is worship’d in them, but the
frugality of the Owners, whose Business it is to procure as much Sound for
as little Money as they can, and the Policy of the Government, who
endeavour
as little as is possible to encourage the Breed of Pipers and
Scrapers. All Sea-faring Men, especially the Dutch, are like the
Element they belong to, much given to loudness and roaring, and the Noise
of half a dozen of them, when they call themselves Merry, is sufficient to
drown twice the number of Flutes or Violins; whereas with one pair of
Organs they can make the whole House ring, and are at no other Charge than
the keeping of one scurvy Musician, which can cost them but little: yet
notwithstanding the good Rules and strict Discipline that are observ’d in
these Markets of Love, the Schout
and his Officers are always vexing, mulcting, and upon the least Complaint
removing the miserable Keepers of them: Which Policy is of two great uses;
first it gives an opportunity to a large parcel of Officers, the
Magistrates make use of on many Occasions, and which they could not be
without, to squeeze a Living out of the immoderate Gains accruing from the
worst of Employments, and at the same time punish those necessary
Profligates the Bawds and Panders, which, tho’ they abominate, they
desire yet not wholly to destroy. Secondly, as on several accounts it
might be dangerous to let the Multitude into the Secret, that those Houses
and the Trade that is drove in them are conniv’d at, so by this means
appearing unblameable, the wary Magistrates preserve themselves in the
good Opinion of the weaker sort of People, who imagine that the Government
is always endeavouring, tho’ unable, to suppress what it actually
tolerates: Whereas if they had a mind to rout them out, their Power in the
Administration of Justice is so sovereign and extensive, and they know so
well how to have it executed, that one Week, nay one Night, might send
them all a packing.
In Italy the Toleration of Strumpets is yet more barefac’d, as
is evident from their publick Stews. At Venice and Naples
Impurity is a kind of Merchandize and Traffick; the Courtezans at
Rome, and the Cantoneras in Spain, compose a Body in
the State, and are under a Legal Tax and Impost. Tis well known, that the
Reason why so many good Politicians as these tolerate Lewd Houses, is not
their Irreligion, but to prevent a worse Evil, an Impurity of a more
execrable kind, and to provide for the Safety of Women of Honour. About
Two Hundred and Fifty Years ago, says Monsieur de St. Didier,
Venice being in want of Courtezans, the Republick was obliged to
procure a great number from Foreign Parts. Doglioni,
who has written the memorable Affairs of Venice, highly extols the
Wisdom of the Republick in this Point, which secured the Chastity of Women
of Honour daily exposed to publick Violences, the Churches and Consecrated
Places not being a sufficient Azylum for their Chastity.
Our Universities in England are much bely’d, if in some Colleges
there was not a Monthly Allowance ad expurgandos Renes:
and time was when the Monks and Priests in Germany were allow’d
Concubines on paying a certain Yearly Duty to their Prelate. ’Tis
generally believ’d, says Monsieur Bayle,
(to whom I owe the last Paragraph)
that Avarice was the Cause of this shameful Indulgence; but it is
more probable their design was to prevent their tempting modest Women, and
to quiet the uneasiness of Husbands, whose Resentments the Clergy do well
to avoid. From what has been said it is manifest, that there is a
Necessity of sacrificing one part of Womankind to preserve the other, and
prevent a Filthiness of a more heinous Nature. From whence I think I may
justly conclude (what was the seeming Paradox I went about to prove) that
Chastity may be supported by Incontinence, and the best of Virtues want
the Assistance of the worst of Vices.